Navigation

Economic Daily: A Current Account Surplus Does Not Mean the Yuan Is Undervalued

2026-11-12 22:24:25 ChinaFXTools 12 reads

Recently, some international voices have labelled the RMB exchange rate as "undervalued" on the grounds of China's current account surplus. That logic, which simply equates the current account with th

Recently, some international voices have labelled the RMB exchange rate as "undervalued" on the grounds of China's current account surplus. That logic, which simply equates the current account with the level of the exchange rate, appears to have theoretical support but in fact departs from how global financial markets actually operate and ignores the deep-seated contradictions of the international monetary system.

The People's Bank of China has published its policy position on the RMB exchange rate, stating explicitly that "the exchange rate is affected by multiple factors, including economic growth, monetary policy, financial markets, geopolitics and sudden risk events, and has no simple linear relationship with the current account". That judgement clears the logical ground for a rational discussion of exchange rate issues and for advancing global economic rebalancing.

From the broader perspective of global financial development, the notion that a surplus determines the exchange rate has long failed to keep pace with reality. Since the Bretton Woods system collapsed in the 1970s, financial liberalisation and globalisation have advanced steadily, and FX market turnover has far outstripped physical trade.

Data published by the PBOC show that the link between trade and exchange rates is weakening. The ratio of global trade volume to global FX turnover fell from about one thirty-fifth in the 1990s to about one seventieth in 2025, while average daily turnover in the global FX market reached nearly US$10 trillion in 2025.

In such a market structure, financial factors — cross-border capital flows, asset price revaluation, monetary policy divergence and shifts in market expectations — exert a more direct and more pronounced influence on exchange rate movements.

For China, funds from current account surpluses are channelled into global markets through outbound investment by companies and banks, the balance of payments has remained broadly balanced, and a current account surplus does not necessarily drive currency appreciation. Discussing the relationship between the current account and the exchange rate while ignoring the financial account is therefore essentially a matter of judging today's market reality with an outdated analytical framework, and the conclusions will inevitably diverge from the facts.

Behind the "surplus means undervaluation" argument lies a deliberate sidestep of the root causes of global economic imbalances, and a simplistic attribution of complex problems in the international monetary system and in economic structure to the RMB exchange rate. Global imbalances are the combined result of the evolution of the international division of labour, the inherent contradictions of the international monetary system and the investment-saving gaps of individual economies; they can by no means be explained by a single exchange rate factor.

Some countries face structural problems of their own — persistently high energy costs, weakening manufacturing competitiveness and insufficient investment in innovation and digitalisation — yet attribute their deficits simply to other countries' exchange rates. Some even used to invoke "respect for market rules" when they themselves ran surpluses, but now, under competitive pressure, call on other countries to let their currencies appreciate. Such double standards do not stand up to the test of history or of present-day reality.

There is no unilateral miracle cure for global economic rebalancing. The key to resolving today's imbalances is for all countries to advance structural reform together. Deficit countries need to undertake fiscal consolidation and raise their savings rates and industrial competitiveness, while surplus countries need to boost consumption and investment. Only when every party shoulders its due responsibility can the global economy become more open, inclusive and balanced.